5 Ways of Finding the Right Power Supply

September 28, 2011 by . 4 comments

Selecting the right power supply is often the last thing people think about when building a computer. However, it is something that deserves substantial consideration. Although spending more on a quality power supply won’t increase your computer’s performance, it would be one of your best investments, because a power supply failure can take the rest of your computer with it. Furthermore, a decent unit will not need to be replaced when newer parts are installed in your computer.

1: Do your research

Power supply quality varies greatly among manufacturers, and even among units from the same manufacturer. Determine the company who actually manufactured the unit, rather than the company who put their brand on it, and make sure they are a reliable company. For example, Corsair units are usually made by either Seasonic or Channel Well, who both make decent units. On the other hand, Allied units which come with some computer cases are made by Solytech, who has been known to make ticking time bombs. This information is usually available by looking up the UL certification number, but often times more research is necessary.

Low-Quality Power Supply with Yellow PCB

Another way to determine power supply quality is from opening the unit up. Quality units will have a green PCB, rather than a beige-yellow one (pictured above). They also have quality capacitors rated for high temperatures, and dedicated protection circuitry. Although the average computer probably isn’t inclined to void their warranty, many power supply reviews contain teardown pictures, as well as expert opinions.

In either case, Tom’s Hardware published a great article with information on how to determine your unit’s quality, as well as a table of manufacturers. It is a great resource for determining power supply quality, and a good read.

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/power-supply-oem-manufacturer,2913.html

Quality Fan Grille compared with Cheap one

Finally, the power supply’s fan grille is a good indication of quality. A fan grille stamped out of metal is a good indication that corners have been cut, since it is the cheapest style of fan grille. The left fan grille pictured above is a quality unit, while the right one is a cheap model.

2: Find a power supply with the 80 Plus designation

80 Plus 80 Plus Bronze 80 Plus Silver 80 Plus Gold 80 Plus Platinum

Even if power consumption from the wall isn’t much of a consideration, the lost energy is turned to heat, necessitating higher velocity fans, resulting in a louder unit. Power supplies bearing the 80 Plus designation and logo have been tested by an independent company who ensures the power supply meets efficiency requirements (80% efficiency at 20%, 50%, and 100% load).

Multiple ratings exist for better efficiencies, although there is little difference between designations. Higher ratings can indicate newer/better units, such as the 80 Plus bronze/silver rated Corsair HX series from 2009, compared to the 80 Plus gold rated Corsair AX series from 2011.

3: Avoid power supplies with multiple 12v rails.

These rails are usually just separate over-current protection units operating from the same 12v source. While they don’t necessarily decrease the efficiency of the power supply, they do make it more difficult to access the 12v current.

OCZ 4-rail unit label

For example, the OCZ600SXS unit is a quad-rail design (pictured above), with two rails to each half of an EPS12v (2×4 pin) CPU connector, one rail to the PCI-e, and one to the motherboard/peripherals. This means that if it were used on a motherboard with an ATX12v (2×2 pin) CPU connector, an entire rail would be lost. Furthermore, even if a very power-efficient CPU (such as a Core i5-2390T) were used, high end graphics cards and multiple graphics card setups could have trouble getting sufficient power.

While most multiple rail power supplies only have two or three rails, it can still prove to be problematic, particularly if one peripheral (such as a graphics card) draws significantly more power than the rest of the system.

4: Read the label!

Checking the power supply wattage is not enough. Make sure that most of the current is available from the 12v output. Modern systems draw the most power from the 12v line. Since this wasn’t always the case, many older designs provide most of the power on the 5v or 3.3v lines, which does no good for modern systems.

For example, consider a Logisys PS480E12 480W power supply, and a Thermaltake TR-380P 380w power supply. While the Logisys unit is rated at a much higher wattage, its 12v current rating is just 16A, whereas the Thermaltake 12v rating is 30A. Therefore, despite the lower power rating, the Thermaltake unit is much better suited for modern computers.

5: Buy a power supply sufficient for your needs, and no more.

Although the market is flooded with high current power supplies, you might be surprised at how little power your computer requires (A quad-core i5-2400 and GTS 450 can require as little as 300 watts).

Furthermore, efficiency of power supplies significantly drops under light use, which is why 80 Plus power supplies aren’t rated for less than 20% loads. While the increase in power consumption may be minimal, higher-wattage power supplies will still get hotter, necessitating more airflow.

OuterVision eXtreme publishes an extensive power supply calculator utility for free, which can give you a great idea of how much power your system needs. The paid version will also tell you how much current on each voltage you should look for.

Feel free to plan for future upgrades. But if you don’t expect to be running large hard drive arrays or multiple graphics cards, don’t waste your money on an overly powerful power supply.

eXtreme PSU Calculator: http://extreme.outervision.com/PSUEngine

Filed under Uncategorized

4 Comments

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  • Gnoupi says:

    Whatever you buy, don’t buy the lowest price. some of them are highly unstable, and even dangerous (see the video):

    http://www.x86-secret.com/dossier-36-3000-Alimentation_Noname.html#suite

    ( http://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=n&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&layout=2&eotf=1&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.x86-secret.com%2Fdossier-36-3000-Alimentation_Noname.html%23suite )

    Some “Noname” PSU are cheating on components, so they can’t even deliver to appropriate current, and often are even dangerous.

  • Daniel says:

    The claim about single rail is interesting one. This means that the OCP will not kick except in extreme conditions. So instead of some recoverable failure of a component you may have much more serious damage to your system. I think that avoid is misleading. You have some quality of life benefits, not having to worry about rail load distribution, but there is minor trade off.

  • Shinrai says:

    I disagree with point five. All your points are correct, but in my experience a power supply that’s run near its rated capacity has a significantly reduced lifespan, and I don’t think it’s worth the tradeoff. My personal policy is to have at least 25% extra capacity from the expected max load draw of your machine. It also makes it much easier to upgrade down the road if you’ve got some overhead and you don’t have to worry about replacing the PSU as well.

    Now, if the immediate cost of the upgrade is a concern, obviously this is a non-issue; you buy what’s in the budget. I’m not suggesting you go put a 1000W PSU in your HTPC either, of course. :)

  • Dan Neely says:

    I’d also advocate having a fair amount of headroom for noise reasons. If you look at fan vs load curves for PSUs you’ll see that with a family of PSUs the fan typically stays at idle until the last X watts where X is the same for the entire family. eg if a 450W unit doesn’t start spinning the fan up until 200W the equivalent 600W model will remain at idle until 350W. If you’re trying to build a quiet/silent system, sizing your PSU so that even at high load the fan stays at low RPM is critical even if it means paying a penalty with a slightly lower efficiency when the system is idling.

  • Leave a comment

    Log in
    with Stack Exchange
    or